Will Angels escort you to the Heavenly realm?  Scripture says nothing about this.
Will Angels escort you to the Heavenly realm? Scripture says nothing about this.

If we comb through the scriptures, we will never find a reference telling us that the final destination of believers is YHVH’s Heavenly Realm, [1] yet this is what we are traditionally taught in the church – in every denomination – despite the fact that Y’shua said, “No one has ascended to heaven except He who came down from heaven, the Son of Man.” (John 3:13(And a whole lot of people had already died when He said this.) 

What DOES Scripture teach?

The dead do not praise YHVH, nor do any who go down into silencePsalm 115:17 NKJV

For the living know that they will die, but the dead know nothingEcclesiastes 9:5

These things He said, and after that He said to them, “Our friend Lazarus sleeps, but I go that I may wake him up.”  Then His disciples said, “Lord, if he sleeps he will get well.”  However, Y’shua spoke of his death, but they thought that He was speaking about taking rest in sleep.  Then Y’shua said to them plainly, “Lazarus is dead. John 11:11-14

Behold, I tell you a mystery: We shall not all sleep, but we shall all be changed—in a moment, in the twinkling of an eye, at the last trumpet [referring to the trumpet blown when Messiah returns]. For the trumpet will sound, and the dead will be raised incorruptible, and we shall be changed. For this corruptible must put on incorruption, and this mortal must put on immortality.  1Corinthians 15:51-53

For this we say to you by the word of the Lord, that we who are alive and remain until the coming of the Lord will by no means precede those carried up who are asleep. For the Lord Himself will descend from Heaven with a shout, with the voice of an archangel, and with the trumpet of God. And the dead in Messiah will rise first. Then we who are alive and remain shall be caught up together with them in the clouds to meet the Lord in the air. And thus we shall always be with the Lord.  1Thess 4:15-17

But the rest of the dead lived not again until the thousand years were finished…  Rev 20:5

We have written more about this in our article, The Importance of the Kingdom To Believers, but the pretty consistent message of scripture (as well as the teaching of the Jews since ancient times) is that we live; we physically die; we remain in an unconscious state until Messiah comes; at which time believers are raised from the dead to rule and reign with Him.  The rest of the dead are raised at the end of the Millennial Kingdom, at which time they are judged.

So where did the idea of believers ‘going to heaven” come from?

Most Cultures Have a Theory of Afterlife
Burial Chamber
Egyptian royal burial chamber

The belief in an afterlife has been found pretty universally in the cultures of the world.  We often hear of an ancient grave being discovered in which are deposited all of the deceased’s most treasured possessions, and even food, for use in the afterlife. Belief in an afterlife almost seems to be instinctive – which we cannot help but see as one of the ways YHVH has given us to be aware of Him and our accountability to Him!

Unfortunately, man finds it forever tempting to reject what YHVH has planned, and so we find that in many (perhaps all) cultures, the belief in an afterlife was eventually ‘put down’ by more ‘enlightened’ individuals who taught a number of different theories that conflict with YHVH’s actual plan.  This is no surprise – the enemy is always at work appealing to the lusts of the flesh and the pride of life, and we regularly fall for his lies!

The various cultural theories of afterlife are a fascinating line of study, but much too complex for this little essay. This discussion will be limited to the cultural views of the afterlife that prevailed at the time of Y’shua in Israel and in the Greco-Roman world of the early centuries of the Church.

First Century Beliefs

The ancient Greco-Roman world for the most part either denied an afterlife, or believed that an afterlife would be lived as a spirit in a spirit world. [2]  The Greeks viewed the human body as glorious and perfect, and had no concept of the corrupting effect of sin on the body. For this reason, the Greco-Roman never envisioned restoration of the flesh to a pre-corrupted state.

The Jews, on the other hand, never entertained the idea of living as spirits, though it appears that even early on in biblical times, they envisioned death as the spirit still existing, but in an unconscious state. [3]  Everything they knew about the history of Man and YHVH indicated to them that Man was designed to live in a physical world and that he should “keep to his own estate,” unlike Satan, who left his own estate (the spiritual realm) in defiance of YHVH. (Jude 1:6)  Man would be physically resurrected at the coming of Messiah, and would dwell in this world or a remade world.  We see this understanding in the account of the raising of Lazarus:

“Lord, if You had been here, my brother would not have died. But even now I know that whatever You ask of God, God will give You.”  Y’shua said to her, “Your brother will rise again.”  Martha said to Him, “I know that he will rise again in the resurrection AT THE LAST DAY.”  John 11:21-24

Like most Jews, Martha expected that the dead would be resurrected, but not until “the last day” – and notice that Y’shua does not ‘correct’ her.  Her belief system did not include “going to Heaven,” nor did Y’shua teach such a concept.  Martha’s understanding agrees with Scripture.

The Hebrew Scriptures (The OT) actually say or imply little regarding afterlife or resurrection, though there is some mention of it. The Scriptures are primarily focused on informing us how to live in this life.  As a result, many Jews of Y’shua’s day did not believe in an afterlife, let alone in the resurrection of the physical body.  This group was primarily represented by the Sadducee party.

Jewish Ossuary of the First Century - a year after death, bones would be gathered and placed in these boxes in preparation for the resurrection
Jewish Ossuary of the First Century – a year after death, bones would be gathered and placed in these boxes in preparation for the resurrection

Many other Jews, however, were convinced that there was an afterlife, and they were prepared to believe that it included resurrection of the flesh. In fact, their view was that Messiah was coming to establish an eternal earthly Kingdom, and they were anxious to be part of it. They understood the necessity of an eternal physical body if they were to live in an eternal earthly kingdom. This view was taught primarily by the Essenes and by the Pharisees (who did get a few things right!).

The New Testament Church

Enter the Messianic community we call The First Century Church or The New Testament Church. (They called themselves “The Way” or “Nazarenes.”)

meet Him in the air
A suggested view of what it might look light when we “meet Him the air”

The accepted doctrine of The Way, established by the apostles and accepted by early believers, stated that believers would be ‘raised from the grave to meet Messiah ‘in the air’ (1Thess 4:16, 1Cor 15:52) at the First Resurrection; that their bodies would be ‘made incorruptible flesh (1Cor 15:52); and that they would live and reign with Messiah over ‘the kingdoms of this world.’ (Rev 11:15, Dan 7:27)

We find the disciples asking Y’shua: Lord, wilt thou at this time restore again the kingdom to Israel? (Acts 1:6) Their question makes it clear that, like other Jews of their day, they expected Messiah to rule an earthly Kingdom. Y’shua did not correct that perception – His reply reflected the standpoint that their question was based in fact.  He simply told them that it was not their business to know when the Kingdom would be fully established.

Roman Government and Gentile Converts

Within only a couple of generations, the burgeoning Gentile membership of the fledgling church began to markedly outnumber the Israelite membership, pulling power away from Jerusalem and toward Rome. With the restraining effect of the apostles gone, power-seeking men began finding their way into leadership, and began twisting the body away from the early faith. This is testified to by multiple early Christian historians, such as Hegesippus.

The “Fiscus Judaicus” was a very heavy tax levied by the Romans against Jews and those who “practiced Jewish Customs.” Anyone who did not pay could be thrown into slavery.

This process was greatly affected by the prevailing attitude of the Roman government, which was hostile to the Jews (for political reasons), engendering a situation in which it was very expensive and literally dangerous to be identified with the Jews. [4]  As Gentile believers sought to remove themselves from the arena of financial and political difficulties attached to the “Jewish” practices of their faith, a Gentile-centric (i.e. pagan-influenced) viewpoint began to prevail in the Body.

Church leadership made an unfortunate response to the Roman threat. Rather than teaching the true main message of The Gospel of Messiah’s Eternal Kingdom – which in Roman eyes was a rebellious “Jewish” political idea centered on the political entity of the kingdom of Judea – emphasis began to be laid on the salvation of the individual through the atoning death and resurrection of the Savior (whose identity as an observant Jew began to be obscured). This was a ‘spiritual’ and apolitical message that could be accepted by any culture, since the focus was placed on the individual rather than on a cultural connection to Israel or Judea.

This doctrinal shift, though technically still orthodox and based in the genuine desire to protect existing believers and make it possible for new believers to enter the ranks, nevertheless resulted in a skewed understanding of Y’shua’s primary purpose and message – the establishment of the Kingdom.

Ancient Pagan Beliefs Entered with the Greek Converts

It was inevitable that the pervasive Greco-Roman culture would affect the faith – often without believers even being aware of it.

Greek afterlife
Greeks and Romans who believed in an afterlife pictured the disembodied spirit being ferried to a dark underworld existence – Gentile converts found the idea of going to Heaven a far better option!

Deprived of careful training in the Tanakh (Old Testament) because of anti-Jewish sentiment, and influenced by the underlying assumptions of their culture (ex: the dead become disembodied spirits) which were so basic and intrinsic to their cultural life, those Gentile beliefs appeared to be the ‘right’ way to look at things. As they studied scripture through that cultural lens, they found it ‘right’ and natural to envision themselves living the afterlife ‘in Heaven’ as spirit beings. Their concept of the resurrection of the dead focused on the spirit and essentially ignored the flesh.

The Gentile converts did not understand that the writers of the NT documents had used ‘code phrases’ (the Kingdom of Heaven, the Kingdom of God) to refer to the earthly Kingdom for fear of the Roman government’s mis-perception that the establishment of the Kingdom would involve political rebellion.

As a result, when the Gentiles read the many scriptural statements about “The Kingdom of Heaven” in which believers will dwell, they assumed that these statements referred to the spiritual (Heavenly) realm in which YHVH dwells. They failed to understand that in the original Hebrew of the Old Testament, when YHVH speaks of His Kingdom, it is always referred to as “YHVH’s Kingdom” or “the Kingdom of Israel,” and He is always referring to His faithful body of followers on earth.

Ought ye not to know that YHVH Elohim of Israel gave the kingdom over Israel to David for ever, even to him and to his sons by a covenant of salt? … And now ye think to withstand the kingdom of YHVH in the hand of the sons of David…. 2Chron 13:5, 8

And in the days of these kings the God of heaven will set up a kingdom which shall never be destroyed; and the kingdom shall not be left to other people; it shall break in pieces and consume all these kingdoms, and it shall stand forever.   Dan 2:44

Then to Him was given dominion and glory and a kingdom, That all peoples, nations, and languages should serve Him. His dominion is an everlasting dominion, Which shall not pass away, And His kingdom the one Which shall not be destroyed.   Dan 7:14

And the seventh angel sounded; and there were great voices in heaven, saying, The kingdoms of this world are become the kingdoms of our Lord, and of his Messiah; and he shall reign for ever and ever.   Rev 11:15

 Misunderstanding Becomes Doctrine

Christianity spread into other pagan lands, and those cultures, too, often believed in an afterlife lived in spirit form.  As they ‘converted’ to Christianity (often a very superficial or even forced conversion), they carried this belief with them, envisioning themselves as joining YHVH in His spiritual realm.

By the time of the Dark Ages (about 500 CE through 1500 CE), the scriptures were no longer available to the general congregation. Often even priests did not have access to the Word – or could not read it even if they did have access! You can imagine the polluted teaching that occurred during the 1,000-year-period in which the average believer had no access to the Word and had to rely on the teaching of men who often had no access to the Word themselves, but were in turn relying on instructions from the Vatican….!

Without proper teaching, the pagan concept of ‘going to Heaven’ had no opposition and was readily accepted by the average believer, who just wanted “out” of his painful fleshly existence.

Are you beginning to see where the modern western Christian idea of “going to Heaven” came from?

Road Map

this-way-signOur fervent hope is that you will consider this article a ‘guide post’ directing you to further study on this topic. This is simply a layman’s quick overview of a fascinating and complex development within the church. There is much information available that will give you a more thorough understanding and that will help the reader reconnect with the historic faith of our forebears. As Y’shua instructed us:

But seek ye first the kingdom of God, and his righteousness; and all these things shall be added unto you. (Matt 6:33)

So He [Y’shua] said to them, “When you pray, say: Our Father in heaven, Hallowed be Your name. Your kingdom come: Your will be done on earth as it is in heaven.”  Luke 11:2 (NKJV)

John and Sue Wyatt (

© John and Sue Wyatt and The Lamb’s Servant Blog, 2014.  Permission to use and/or duplicate original material on The Lamb’s Servant Blog is granted, provided that full and clear credit is given to John and Sue Wyatt and The Lamb’s Servant Blog, with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.

[1] We DO find references telling us that we will dwell in the Kingdom of Heaven, but these verses refer to the earthly Kingdom founded and ruled by Heaven – i.e. Heaven’s Kingdom.  Please see our article entitled The Importance of the Kingdom To Believers

[2] “…death was not a glorious thing for the ancient Greeks. In Homer’s epics, the dead are ‘pathetic in their helplessness, inhabiting drafty, echoing halls, deprived of their wits, and flitting purposelessly about uttering batlike noises.’ While undesirable when compared with life on earth, this vague, shadowing [sic] existence was not generally cause for fear of the afterlife. Only terrible sinners (like Tantalus, Tityus and Sisyphus) were punished after death; similarly, only a select few ended up in the paradisiacal Elysian Fields…” (Greco-Roman Religious Beliefs,

[3] Jewish Beliefs on the Afterlife,

[4]  By the year 96 C.E., it was equated with treason to “adopt the Jewish way of life.” Those who were already following “Jewish customs” (such as circumcision, celebrating the Feasts, etc.) – including Gentile Messianic Christians – had to pay an enormous tax, the Fiscus Judaicus. If the tax was not fully paid, they could be thrown into slavery. This tax, established early on in the existence of the church, played a huge part in drawing Gentile believers away from Torah. (Christopher Quinn, The Growing Split Between Synagogue and Church in the 1st Century: The Fiscus Judaicus)



  1. Excellent approach to this subject! Like so many biblical issues the teaching we have received through the ages comes in large part from ignorance and wishful thinking. There are still so many puzzling questions about the afterlife, but the tragic thing is not that the questions exist, but that so few are willing to ask the questions and follow the path of answers no matter how uncomfortable YHVH’s truth is to our fallen human sensibilities. Yet the closer we get to His full revelation, the greater and more glorious and more satisfying it is.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks for taking the time to read it, “Fox.” You are so right – for many, many years as a very active and ‘devout’ Christian, I ignorantly accepted the paradigm that “studying the Bible” meant reading a portion (usually the NT) with some friends, getting the leader’s input, and then discussing our own ‘take’ on it. Does that sound like any “Bible Study” session you might have attended? It describes ALL the hundreds of sessions I attended! The result? We all had a very good understanding of what our denomination THOUGHT and TAUGHT about the Bible, and a great understanding of how our peers were applying the passages in their lives, but we never allowed the scriptures to speak for THEMSELVES. We were either blinded by what we had been taught or too afraid to ‘rock the boat’ by asking awkward questions. I secretly comforted myself with the thought that “Someday I will be spiritual enough that I will understand.” SO SAD!!

      Y’shua promised us that His Truth would set us free, and that is exactly what husband John and I found once we began allowing the scriptures to tell us what we should believe, rather than listening to teachers. What a HUGE difference!!! There is so much more yet to learn, but what we have learned so far has made our faith walk so much more satisfying. It’s wonderful to find others who have made that same discovery! Thanks so much for sharing. 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Hi Sue,

    Thank you for visiting my blog. Your posts are very interesting, especially this one. I also checked your post ‘The Importance of the Kingdom to Believers’ in your other blog. I am glad you mentioned Luke 16:20-31; 23:43 and; Matt 22:31-32 as I was thinking of that—in addition to the prophet Samuel “coming back from the dead”, Elijah and Moses appearing with Jesus during the Transfiguration, and the martyrs in Revelation 6:10.

    By chance, I am also reading the book of Job at the moment, where he seems to me to have the same view as you express here.

    But you and John are right, whether we go to “sleep” or not, [I quote you] “our peace and comfort to know that Y’shua is in control of this matter, and that whatever the process of death and resurrection actually is, we can depend on Him to manage it righteously and justly”.

    The Lord bless you and may He continue to reveal Himself to you.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Thanks so much for taking the time to read and comment. I have been enjoying your blog, too – your heart is tender toward our Messiah!

    Yes, I too desire that He will “continue to reveal Himself to” me – and to each of us. He will probably continue to reveal Himself throughout eternity – He is endless and boundless in His mercy, grace, justice and righteousness!!

    Shalom and blessings.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Hi Sue! I love that you are a Truth seeker, as we all should be. I no longer celebrate Halloween after doing MUCH research on it, but I do celebrate Christmas and Easter not focusing or taking part in their pagan origins. I do have a question regarding this post though. What about the MANY testimonies of people who have died and gone to heaven and hell for a time before coming back to life? Where would our souls go if not to heaven or hell upon death? Just curious as to your thoughts on this. Blessings!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Hi, Jennifer! Thanks so much for taking the time to read and discuss this. I wish I could give you an authoritative answer, but I can’t. My unfounded thoughts are: Many researchers who have looked into this subject believe that the brain remains active for a period after the heart stops, and that people are actually experiencing visions rather than reality. Having personally experienced a number of visions, I can testify that they were given to me to help me redirect my faith and actions and to allow me to better understand things from YHVH’s perspective. Perhaps YHVH did the same for these folks? And did they see heaven, or did they see the recreated and renewed earth?

      Where DO our souls go upon death? The scriptures (and Y’shua) refer to ‘Abraham’s bosom’, which appears to be the Hebraic euphemism for a time of sleep while awaiting resurrection. Obviously it must be a ‘place’ of some sort, but the Word gives us no indication of where or what it is. Is it in another dimension?

      As I said in the article, there is so much that we don’t know about death, but we can gratefully rest in the sure knowledge that Y’shua understands and is in full control. 🙂 Thanks so much for taking the time to read this and to truly think about it. I’d really like to hear your response to what I have suggested here. Thanks!!

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Thanks for your prompt reply. 🙂 I suppose that is a possibility. I thought Abraham’s Bosom was where the believer’s went before the coming of Christ, and when Jesus descended into hell and took the keys, he took everyone in Abraham’s Bosom up with him. (Of course that is what I have been told.) We have been told a lot it seems. My brother and sister-in-law became Messianic and it tore the family apart. They weren’t going to come to my wedding because it was on a Friday evening, didn’t make my graduation because it was on a Saturday, etc. They sent out DVDs called “Tradition or Occult” or something like that along with a letter that was very condemning. There son went from Christian, to Muslim, to Messianic, and now is Atheist. It’s all of the legalism that got to him from what he’s said. It’s a shame. 😦 More recently they brother and sis-in-law have been doing things on Saturdays and they even attended Christmas with my family last year (their son was in town, and eventhough he is Atheist, he now “celebrates” the holiday). So, “religion” is a touchy subject in my family and has pushed my other brother (who is atheist as well) further from even wanting anything to do with it. :-/ It just makes me so sad. I believe in honoring God, following the Torah to the best of my abilities, but also remembering that there is grace. ❤

        Liked by 1 person

        1. Sorry to say, your family’s story sounds familiar. Seems like there are several stages that people go through as they adjust to the understanding of Torah, much like new Christians who wave their Bibles in everyone’s face and then gradually settle down into the Walk. For messianics, the first stage tends to be anger at the church system for having ‘lied’ to them, combined with a strident insistence on the ‘letter of the law.’ This usually results in some unfortunate mistakes (like refusing to go to a wedding on a Sabbath), because they don’t really even understand the LETTER of the law yet, let alone its spirit! Unless they have a trusted and mature messianic mentor to disciple them, it takes a while for most folks to get past that stage of anger and legalism. Gradually compassion begins to overcome the anger, and the believer is ready to begin actually growing in his faith.

          I’ve been in Torah for almost 6 years now, and I still feel like I am in the infancy stage. We made some bad mistakes with our family, too – and they made some bad responses. Like you say, Grace is the key! We have been forgiven much, and we would be foolish not to forgive in return.

          As far as a believer’s behavior ‘pushing someone away from faith,” I’m afraid I just don’t ‘buy’ that. YHVH has promised that if a person TRULY wants to know Him, He will give them every opportunity to do so. Lots of Christians pushed their faith at me and were obnoxious in the extreme, but it never stopped me from wanting a TRUE relationship with YHVH and Messiah. He faithfully honored that desire. When people say, “I don’t believe because (fill in the blank),” the real reason is because they don’t WANT to believe. All we can do is pray that their attitude will change, because one of two things will happen to them: (1) YHVH will put them into situations where they NEED to call on Him (no fun….) or (2) they will continue to reject Him to the point that He will harden their hearts past repentance. So PRAY! And let us all show His Grace toward one another!!! Thank you for sharing – Sometimes I take a kind of “hard line” in my writing, and it’s good to be reminded to practice Grace in my writing as well! ❤

          Liked by 1 person

          1. Thank you so much for your lengthy reply and understanding. I agree, people make many excuses for not believing, but when it comes to my nephew I think he really was over the legalism. At least that’s what he told my brother-in-law through FB messaging. My hubby shared a quote about atheism and my nephew started a debate. That’s when he got introduced to by bro-in-law who also likes to “debate”. So, they continued the conversation via FB messenger. He opened up quite a bit to him about all he has been learning, as well as his background with his family and faith.

            He grew up Christian, then Lutheran, then Christian, than got deployed to the Middle East with the Marines and returned a Muslim . . . That’s about the time my bro and sis-in-law turned Messianic. He eventually got on board after visiting his mom and dad and turned full on. However, it didn’t last very long (as most people caught up in legalism get worn out), and he turned atheist. It’s just nuts. I honestly don’t know my brother and his wife’s current religion (it’s a sore subject) but I know they no longer “steal away” on the Sabbath, and she commented on a FB post of his about Atheism saying that she is proud of him and how wise he is . . . All we can do is pray, and that I am doing! My own brother and sis-in-law aren’t even my FB friends because of our differences (they unfriended me). I’ll admit that I did struggle with a religious spirit for awhile there, and my pastor finally told me that although everything I am posting on FB is truth, I need to be aware of the motive behind it and how it could be received. I have grown a LOT needless to say. I have a great relationship with them now, we just aren’t FB friends, lol.

            Anyway, I look forward to reading some more of your posts, I just need to carve out the time. Believe it or not for being immobile for three months I am staying pretty busy! Blessings! ❤

            Liked by 1 person

  5. If I’d had to travel the confusing road your nephew has traveled, I think I might have declared myself an atheist, too – just to get some breathing room and some time to sort things out!

    Some of the strongest believers I know are people who at one time rejected the whole ‘religious thing’ – they were smart enough to recognize that their religious community wasn’t living out what they described as Truth, so rather than settle for hypocrisy, they just left the whole thing. Most of them lived pretty rebellious lives, some for quite a long time. But their hearts really wanted TRUTH, and YHVH answered their call. “Blessed are they which do hunger and thirst after righteousness: for they shall be filled.” (Matt 5:6) I hope that happens for your nephew, too.

    I sure have been enjoying your creative writing stuff – you are gifted! It shows in your devotional writing, too. I’m looking forward to seeing more. 🙂 Blessings, and Shabbat Shalom! ❤


  6. After coming to Torah, I started noticing more and more verses that countered my “heaven after death” belief. I have to admit that this subject is one that did NOT rock my world as much as some of the others did! It was the no “pre-Trib rapture” thing that freaked me out! Mainly because I was concerned (I don’t think my husband was) that our children would walk away from the faith after finding out the truth. But that only showed MY lack of trust in Father! After sharing with our kids what the Holy Spirit was revealing to us – they said that it made more sense – and they have been with us on this journey to Torah with just as much joy as we have!! Hallelujah!

    Even though my understanding about heaven has changed, and I believe it is firmly founded on Scripture, I don’t bring this up with my friends and family. They are still processing the no Sunday church/Christmas/Easter part, so I don’t want to overwhelm with anything else at this point.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. You are a wise woman, Christy. This is a topic that I leave quietly in the background – it is not critical to guiding our faith walk, and it can be a hard thing for some believers to handle without preparation such as you had as you found scriptures that challenged the traditional belief.

      I’ve found that those readers who find my articles about Heaven do so under the guidance of the Ruach, and that is exactly how it should be! He is SO FAITHFUL!!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s